How to Leave Comments
68In the very short time I’ve been with HubPages, I’ve mellowed out while reading, commenting, and Hopping Hubs. I consider myself firm and fair because of my time in law enforcement, but this last Hub I had written earlier this week has given me insights on why my views of reading and reviewing Hubs have changed and will continue to improve for the better.
I have also stuck by what I have felt all along. I do not appreciate anyone who thinks they are “helping” me by correcting my Hubs or telling me how I should write them. When I first started writing for HubPages, I was appalled to see so many Hubbers willing to welcome emails from total strangers who were willing to correct a Hub’s spelling, grammar and punctuation.
I still find that an insult, but I got a few dings from Hubbers who have written less than three Hubs. Not that much writing experience, if you ask me. I never appreciated know-it-alls trying to tell me what to do. But since these Hubbers were fairly new, I give them that much for trying to be helpful. Then I ignore them and move on. With so little time on HubPages, I can't say I take these people or whatever they say seriously.
What I publish is my responsibility, and that includes any errors that I have made and feel I am responsible for. I am not an editor. I am a writer. But I struggle with the editing and prefer to do it on my own without anyone’s help.
If, you are one of those poor unfortunates who took the time to tell me that I should write to your specifications, I am not not going to please you. In fact, surprise, surprise. I will tell you that I don’t appreciate your input. I prefer people to butt out of my writing process because they certainly don’t belong in my world of writing. If I need help, I will ask for it.
I had this happen to me recently. Yes, I can respect a Hubber who is established and has communicated with me in the past. I will absolutely accept their point of view. But if the Hubber has barely got a profile, no profile shot or barely an acceptable profile to their name, then you will be hearing from me.
These inexperienced critics are waste my time. Whether they want to believe it or not, their tries at being critics are failed attempts, and I simply blow them off and move on. I may sound rude when I reply to their petty remarks, but I am one who has dealt with many critics in the past. There is no doubt I have critics in my present and more in my future. Believe me. I can take it. You will not see me go to a corner and pout. Nor will I have my tail between my legs and hide.
I am not a people pleaser. I have enough experience in writing to be confident to state my views and stand behind them, and this is why:
I am using my legal name. Therefore, I’m automatically telling you I mean business.
What makes it difficult about pen names is that if your pen name is too cutesy, how can I take you serious, anyway? Am I really talking to a real person or an alter ego? A cutesy pen name loses credibility in terms of communication.
I rely on a Hubber’s profile and photograph. If they’re not there, I won’t read the Hub and I will move on.
I have written a Hub on the importance of writing a Hub profile. I will read every Hub profile with every Hub I read. I expect that profile to tell me about the person writing the Hub. If a writer can’t do something as simple as putting his profile out there, then I feel that he is not totally interested in publishing his work for an audience and taking Hubpages seriously.
Since joining HubPages as a writer since June 2011, I have seen so many people come and go because they didn’t have staying power. When they couldn’t make money right away, they quit. There are quite a few established writers on HubPages. Those are the people who inspire me.
I now respect each Hubber’s writing journey and don’t expect everyone to write the same.
Now, I have learned to drop all expectations and just enjoy the writing.
I know each writer has their own style of writing. I have come to respect that, so I am very careful when I leave my comments. All I ask for now is something that I would value to read for later. Most of the Hubs I have read and appreciated have made it to my bookmark file. Not only do I read Hubs, Hub Hop and comment on any Hub that I find delightful, I do want to read good copy and layout at a later time. I am looking forward to the rainy weather and being able to catch up with these bookmarks.
I am generous with praise.
I do like the majority of Hubs that I read, so I do vote them up and hit the other positive rating keys in reach.
I become a follower and remain supportive.
A lot of times, I will not catch a writer’s work. But I will follow anyone who has a string of interesting Hubs. I will follow a promising new Hubber. I encourage people to keep writing—no matter what. I do know a lot of writers drop out. I want to be part of the force to encourage new writers to stay.
I will always to be kind with my comments.
Other than shutting down the know-at-all who tells me I should write their way, my focus is on the comments I leave to Hub writers.
I will not step over boundaries and tell a writer how to write. A major thing I find so wrong about this is that I am not a Hubber’s English professor, editor, critic or boss. I have no power over this person, and it is not my business. I am not in the business and paid for any of these roles.
HubPages is much too generous when it gives Hubbers the chance to either approve or accept a comment. As a rule, I don't chose to use the Deny key. I do believe that everyone should be allowed to express their opinion, and so do I. I will not put up with any criticism towards my writing. I'm talking about the ones who are telling me how to write. This is not what I feel HubPages is set up for. I will simply read these negative views, answer to them, and move on.
Inexperienced writers and readers don't seem to realize that their comments will not automatically get the writer to change the Hub. In fact, their negativity is ignored when it comes to dealing with me. I'm listening to what they are saying, but then again, I'm not. I stand behind my writing because I write to please me. At the same time, if your negative remarks appear on my comments section, keep in mind they will stay there for others to read. I have no control over your rudeness.
I will only leave encouragement and comments for the Hubbers who put their work out there. I will be very careful about this. I have read profiles, and many writers have expressed fear of being judged or admitting they cannot take criticism well.
Criticism is good or bad
Until a writer can develop thick skin and bounce back from critics, I won’t test the waters. That's not my job. Some writers will not develop that thick skin at all. I have been writing for most of my life. I have pride in my writing, and so should you. If you leave something negative for a Hubber, keep in mind that there is a possibility that you could destroy that person’s confidence or self-esteem. Without even knowing it, your remarks could make the writer quit writing altogether. Now that would be a tragedy. Just because you don’t personally know this person doesn’t mean you have the right to be cruel.
Don’t worry about me.
If I have a problem with your comments, I won’t hesitate to let you know. I do bounce back from the worst of times, and someone’s comments have no effect on me as a writer. There is nothing anyone can do to make me change the way I write. Believe me. It will not ruin my day. As an experienced writer, I can usually read a post and figure out if that person is inexperienced as a writer. I won’t have to read your profile because I know.
Don’t ever think your criticism will hurt me because I won’t take your unacceptable behavior as a personal assault. But I will call you on it if you feel I should be writing for you because you say so. Writers with years of experience know how to do this, but I do have respect for those who are just beginning to find their voice as writers.
I only wish these Hubbers well and support them in their search to be better writers.
vote upvote downshareprintflag
- Useful (8)
- Funny
- Awesome (10)
- Beautiful
- Interesting (7)
CommentsLoading...
I had to change my hub comment setting from unmoderated to moderated. All my hub comments were unmoderated until I published my hub on Ellery Queen-until then comments would show up right away and I would wake up in the morning to comments which everyone else had already read before me. Since I never intended to deny a comment that disagreed with me, I didn't see the need to moderate anything.
Then I got a new follower who thought that it was halarious that I used the picture of a pen for my photograph on the hub. Originally, I thought it was a legitimate question and told the hubber that since Ellery Queen was a pen name, I would use a pen as a photo.
Soon I got several comments in the space of an hour such as
"But it is only a pen!"
"Boooooooooring pen"
"let's talk about pencils!"
You get the idea. now everything is moderated. I tried to get the hubber banned for harassing me, but no luck.
Hi Arlene. You've had a busy day. I couldn't help watching from the sidelines.
It is true, you always leave kind and generous comments on my articles, as well as those of others. Your sense of humor and honesty are real, and those qualities always come through in whatever you write. Just by the length of most of your comments alone, it is obvious you love to write and are passionate about your profession!
I knew it, I knew that this kind of hub was following after the comment rage on the last. Way to go speak up and speak out sister.
Personally I choose to hide my face and name for now, mainly because god gifted me with an extremely wild imagination and I fear some psycho corn stalker will knock on my door in the middle of the night. It happens you know, I seen it on tv.
But big kudos for stating your stance. I got your back, I know my way around knives.
Well said, Arlene.
I think the only time I hit the deny button was when someone was trying to use my hubs to draw attention to their own - quite obviously so...not good in my view. We all have things that get our backs up I s'pose.
That said... I was an English Teacher in my day now a one-to-one tutor, I know I have some typo's in my hubs and I will get round to correcting them one day when I have finished reviewing, correcting (punctuation and grammar), editing, the work of writers who contact me for help. I don't do the chasing, I certainly wouldn't dream of sending an email trying to correct someone's hubs - bit too personal, that!
Voted up, useful, awesome and interesting.
Helena
Okay, I'll fess up. JamaGenee IS the REAL me because I do genealogy (aka "chasing dead people") in my jammies. Was supposed to be JamaGenIE but I lost my password when I first joined HP and the HP team didn't reply to "what's my password" so I started over as JamaGenEE. Whew!
But if you prefer, I also answer to Joanna. There's another JamaGenie, btw, on StumbleUpon, a blonde 20-something from Canada. Found her one night when I was Googling myself - don't knock it if ya haven't tried it. Turns out JG was her nickname since she was knee high to a grasshopper and the only reason it wasn't rejected as her SU screen name is because I had a brain fart and varied the spelling when I signed up. (Hey, I was new to the social networking thing and was told NOT to use the same screen name everywhere.)
As for that DENY button, in almost 3 1/2 years at HP, I've only used it twice. Once for a "comment" that was nothing but a link to the guy's commercial website and once for a "comment" that contained more swear words than even my career-Navy daughter knows.
*Almost* used the button recently for a comment from a troll, but instead I took three deep breaths, counted to 10, and let my Brit ancestry come out with a reply that to a non-Brit would appear *extremely* civil, but was actually a direct shot to the jugular. ;D
I was wondering about those handcuffs. And then I think it was on your hub with the spinning wheel I started a comment something about handcuffs and spinning wheels and what's going on at your house - but I changed my mind and erased it. So, thanks for clearing the origin of the handcuffs for me.
On one of my first hubs (aspartame and depression) a woman left a comment basically disagreeing with me based on her experiences and I approved it, because to open a discussion was sort of my goal. I don't mind an a good debate at all and would never deny a comment just because someone did not agree with me. I provided her with my sources that she requested. But the links didn't open for her because they had periods on the end and so they were broken. She then basically said I must not have read my sources lately and it was starting to seem like a bit of an attack on my credibility. But, I of course approved her comment - really no reason not to. She did thank me though for not denying her comment. It actually all seemed liked a rather odd exchange to me at the time, especially since this was the first time I really dealt with people's online comments.
I don't deny comments, and only have for a couple of comments that were basically spam and one other where a guy said something about how to see other people's google id numbers. He even said I might not want to approve his comment. I chose not to, because his fears were simply unfounded and I had a lot of people reading that particular hub. His comment would have been the equivalent of screaming "fire" in a theatre when no fire existed.
Wonderful! Another bathrobe wanderer! Why go to all the trouble to dress "properly" if ya don't have to. It's YOUR castle. I'm with you, too, on the uninvited. Far as I'm concerned they're in the same group as telemarketers - not worth my time or even a modicum of courtesy. ;D
I have written online here and there for over 4 years and yes I agree with you. I have had corrections from American writers when what I have said is valid in my country the UK. Take for instance the menopause :) In the UK women do have hot flushes and not flashes. I appreciate well wnet messages about typos etc and yes i do make mistakes. Writing is a great learning curve
If one has a functioning brain and spends any amount of time reading the work of those from countries other than America, that mind would have to be closed to NOT absorb the differences in cultures and the words used to communicate them in these pages. I was "knocked up" *several times* when I was in England and none involved sexual intercourse or pregnancy. ;D
Hey, Arlene, you want to tell how you really feel? LOL
I wish I had used my real name when I started, but I do have people in my life who I do not want to find me if at all possible. Then by the time I figured out what I was doing and wanted to change my profile name, I couldn't, so I added the notation in my profile who I was. I still really don't want to be located by certain family members, but they have no idea that homesteadbound is me, nor was I inclined to writing when they knew me, especially since I only stated writing 2 months ago. I hope that sometime it will be possible to change my name to my real name. But to do that now would be like starting over, and I have worked hard for what I have. I am glad that I am following you and you are following me. Between all this following we might even eventually catch up with each other.
I'm with ya - next week in the newsletter you will learn a little more about my situation anyway. But we adopted 3 emotionally disturbed children who are ... well ... how do I say this nicely ... scary at best. We have moved once and through circumstances beyond our control, one of them found us. They will not with the next move. At that time my youngest son tried to kill my husband. So that is what I mean. It's really more of a safety issue. When he was 14 the pychologist told us he was probably a psychopath. His two older siblings are not much better. I know my situation is extreme and not normal. Also my mother who lost custody of me when I was 7 can get very weird, so I would rather not be found by her also. I think I'm the only normal person (twitch, twitch, twitch) in my whole family. My sisters are strange also, but considering what we went through, I can't say that I blame them. I have been lucky in that respect.
Yes, they can, but they don't care. My sisters and my father are alcoholics. I can never understand the people that drink nyquil for a buzz. That stuff is NASTY!
Amen to that!
What is that orange thing you are holding?
Stoppppppppppppppppppp ... you're making me twitch, twitch, twitch.
So Arlene - I was telling my daughter about the lost corn maze family last night, and today she told me that in her high school sociology class someone used that story as a current event article to present. I asked her what kids had to say about it and she said, "nothing because everyone wanted to watch the movie Mean Girls." And people wonder why other countries outrank us in so many things. Anyway, it all made me think of you - the corn maze story, I mean.
So glad you clarified that last comment, ktrapp. You might have gotten her wound up ... LOL
I would like to stay and play, but I'm going to have to take my toys and go home. It's almost 1 a.m. and I'm tired! See you tomorrow - make that later today! :)
one last question ... since this hub is aout how to leave comments, am I doing it right? Enquiring minds want to know ...
sure wish I could type. aout is somrtimes known as about.
and somrtimes is often sometimes
Geez, I stay offline for 12 hours to clean out a few closets and re-arrange the living room and find so many comments here that I forgot which one I was going to respond to.
Oh, wait! I remember now! Getting knocked up in England. Yes, it's the Brit version of our wake-up call. Before telephone were commonly used, a maid or someone from the front desk would knock on the door of your hotel room towake you. A "knock [to wake you] up". The term stuck, but I think some desk male clerks simply get a charge out of the shocked reaction of an American woman traveling abroad for the first time after they ask "Would you like to be knocked up?"! They think the clerk is hitting on them. lol!
As for homesteadbound wanting to remain invisible to certain people, I can certainly relate to that. First, for a year during and after a messy divorce, the ex had a small army of friend girls who had nothing better to do than to stalk me 24/7 and report my every move. Years later I was working in politics in a town with three TV stations, all with roving camera crews, so I didn't dare pop out to the grocery store in grodies for fear of showing up on the 6 o'clock news. Some may like, even crave, the attention from living in a fish bowl, but I never did.
Arlene - I don't think I should be leaving comments late at night. My point was really only about current events and corn mazes, not mean girls. :)
Geez, I go out of town for a couple of days and apparently I've missed a lot. I'm with you on the deny key, Arlene. The only time I've used it is to get rid of duplicate comments (which has happened a couple of times and I don't know why), just to clean things up. I haven't had anybody attack me in the comments yet, so maybe when that happens, I will think differently. I did get an email from someone offering a critique of one of my hubs, which I thought was a bit odd but basically took with a grain of salt.
Now I need to check out the corn maze hub and see what all the fuss was about. : )
That "knocked up" comment had me going. I would definitely be doing a double take if asked that question. LOL
I have interest in having my own children.
Like your new profile pic. I like your style as you tell it as it is --no sugar-coating. As for those who feel that they have the rights to correct every minor detail, oh well, I always look at their intention. If they're out to show that they're better--who cares?--the reader will determine that. But if they are sincerely trying to help me, I take it and am reluctantly grateful. Again, enjoy your thought-provoking hub.
Hi Arlene, wow I glad I didn't read the hub that generated so much vitriol.
Which one was it by the way, just curious lol
I think you are absolutely right. You write your way, it's what you say that matters not how you say it.
Who cares about all rubbish. Look at Shakespeare, considered one of the greatest writers in the English language and he couldn't give a fiddlers toss about spelling punctuation or grammar.
In fact he used this to great effect. And don't even get me started on James Joyce. Or Stephen Hawking for that matter.(pun intended)
I have not used the deny button yet and don't intend too unless it is a link to something nasty.
Publish and be damned I say and to hell with the critics.
I don't see any statues to critics but I do see monuments to great writers.
Keep up the good work.
I remain your humble servant:-) Michael Mulcahy (molometer)
Seems you've stirred up a lot of people. I started with a pen name thinking that was what you should do and as stated above, I am now stuck with it. Since I live in Tillson, NY, Tillsontitan isn't too far a stretch. I enjoyed your hub and all the comments!
Hi Arlene.....you go girl...I only encountered one person who criticized me on one of my hubs and I fired back. I haven't had any one correct me on my spelling or grammar errors yet but I don't think that would bug me. But who knows. Hope you are enjoying this weather and that things are well with you. Mary
God Bless You - I a s glad someone finally wrote this masterpiece.
Voted up and awesome
One time I was waiting in line at a bank, and the lady behind me fixed the tag on my shirt because it was sticking up. Then she told me that she always cut off her tags, and I should do that too. I am grateful when someone corrects something that is easily corrected. Why go around all day with a tag sticking out when it takes one person who notices to speak up.
I didn't however, cut off all the tags from my shirts because she told me to. I prefer to leave them on.
I haven't told anyone in a hub about their error(s), but sometimes when I see a well written hub with a minor problem, I often feel like I should let them know, in case they want to correct it. That's how we learn.
If you see my tag sticking out on my hub, please tell me.
Nicely written Millionaire tips and I agree a hundred per cent!
Hello Arlene,
Your comments are always positive and uplifting. I am always very happy when you pop over to my little corner of the hubiverse and leave me a message.
Great hub this and recommended reading for everyone new to hubpages and maybe some not so new.
Keep the faith... Michael
Well, here we go...
I've been meaning to come to your part of the town and read your writings for some time now, but you know how it is - I always forget. Today I didn't forget, and I can say that I am very glad I didn't. The first time I saw you was in one of the hubs written by our mutual friend Thomas, and I liked your comments right away. Today when I came to your profile, I noticed that you are really a Hubber extraordinaire and definitely worth reading and following.
Now, let's get down to business... I know what you are talking about and I also hate when people with "good intentions" start acting all "I know everything, you know nothing". I had a Hubber contact me saying that I should write in a completely different way, because I am using too many words to get to my point. Although I replied and wanted to hear what he had to say, I never changed my writing style because of what he said...
Anyway, it is sometimes obvious that I use too many words......I do it because I am being honest and trying to leave good comments/write interesting and engaging hubs... AT least I think so :)
As I said, you have got yourself a new follower, and I am glad to be able to browse through your hubs and find a lot of interesting things to read :)
Arlene, as one who regularly takes the long way around from Point A to Point Z via Point M and back to Point F, I see absolutely NOTHING wrong with being wordy. Besides, it drives telemarketers and survey-takers nuts! tee hee
As for the know-it-alls who think they're experts at writing, unless I've specifically asked for their advice, the minute I hear an unsolicited "You should...", I'm gone!
"Women's Studies" section, huh? Yes, I suppose bookshops have to call it that (or something similar), but it's still rather sexist and a perfect example of why books like the one I recommended by Gail Collins HAD to be written in the first place. On the other hand, I have to be glad cookbooks aren't in the same section! ;D
Ah, yes, the Women's Studies "classes" in the '80s. What fun...not. Nobody knew quite what to make of them. Were they fostering true enlightenment for the still-pathetic plight of women...OR just a chance for female students to gripe for an hour or so and earn a few credits in the process?
As for where to find a particular book in a book store, it helps to have some knowledge of Ye Olde Dewey Decimal System used in libraries. Chain bookshops, though, don't always stock what one thinks would be a "popular title, so I usually save the shoe leather and my few remaining working brain cells and go straight from the front door to the Help Desk. I know... That's the lazy way to do it, but it's my experience whoever is behind the counter practically jumps for joy when a customer asks for an "obscure" title instead of "Where's the loo?" or "Why doesn't this sleazy bodice-ripper come in hardback?". ;D
To Arlene: Your premise is an excellent one. Comments regarding hubs should be intelligent and civil to say the least. However, there are those individuals who elect to write somewhat vitiolic comments. Some even regress to mudslinging- well, that is quite uncalled for. My point: if you have nothing positive to say, then DON'T say it and move on. Making positive comments is a form of etiquette and polite behavior; doing otherwise is a sign of poor manners and is totally declasse.
I like your attitude - there is nothing wrong with a positive attitude or sharing a kind word. Some discussions are like the kids in the back yard - no thought or respect.
Thank you
q
I recently deleted a comment someone left on one of my hubs because of the extremely foul and hateful language in it. Only the 3rd or 4th time I've done so in almost 4 years at HP. Rather than have the person post another, even filthier and more hateful comment on finding the first one deleted, I posted one saying I'd deleted the first **because of** the hateful expletives, but added that she made some great points.
Usually that's the end of it, so I was quite surprised when she left another comment making the same points as the first, but sans the filthy, hateful language. That one I didn't delete. A win-win for all.
























ThoughtSandwiches Level 7 Commenter 7 months ago
Hi Arlene...
So in the third paragraph, second sentence...you forgot...lol. Simply funning with you my friend.
I remember the comments you are speaking about...that's when we met and I started following my snarky friend from over the hill...ain't regretted a step of that follow by the way.
That said...ThoughtSandwiches is the alter-ego...of my alter-ego (silent partner kind of thing...)
I always like your style my friend! Voted all the Ups of course...